EPCAL Watch Coalition
156 Young's Avenue, Calverton, NY 11933
631.369.8237
June 2, 2020
The Honorable Yvette Aguiar
Supervisor
Town of Riverhead
200 Howell Avenue
Riverhead, New York 11901
Re:EPCAL: Comments For Addition to Record For
June 2, 2020 Meeting of
Riverhead Town Board
Dear Supervisor Aguiar:
First, thanks for speaking with representatives of the
EPCAL Watch Coalition [EWC] about our concerns.I write on behalf of EWC to continue our discussion and to comment on
the recent letters filed with the town on behalf of Calverton Aviation and
Technology LLC (“CAT”). This letter has also been sent to the Town Clerk, Diane
Wilhelm, as well as to all members of the Town Board.We ask that our letter be posted on the town’s
EPCAL web page and be entered into the official record of the June 2, 2020 Town
Board meeting.
EWC requests that before your office responds to recent
CAT written communications, the Town Board hold an open public discussion of
their content at a work session or Board Meeting in which public comment is included.Uncritical acknowledgement of the letters
from Christopher Kent and Justin Ghermezian may be interpreted legally as a
waiver of the Town’s right to cancel the contract at any time before closing.
Our initial reading is that these two letters add
nothing of substance to the town’s requirement for updated financial
information and a detailed development plan.Moreover, the tone of the letters is both threatening and patronizing,
reminding us of the infamous intervention by the head of the Ghermezian family
that, "You have to hug us. You have to kiss us" because other regions
were "begging" for their investment. Evidently Riverhead’s cost to the Ghermezians
has declined from a $2.5 million inducement for unanimous approval in the Q
& E process to advance payment of $500,000 for which the Town is already
entitled.
We believe the Town must make use of its legal
opportunity to immediately terminate its contract with CAT because CAT has failed
to define its proposed development as required under the Urban Renewal Law.Moreover, although you have repeatedly requested
updated financial information from CAT, appropriate documentation of its
ability to finance the project has yet to be submitted. Finally, contract termination is the only reliable
way to restore to town control the 1,050 environmentally sensitive acres inappropriately
added to the sales contract at no additional cost and without adequate public
hearing and debate.
CAT Has Failed To
Define the Project
As you are aware, the town
is entitled to terminate its contract with CAT because a subdivision map of the
property was not filed with the County of Suffolk by the May 20, 2020 deadline.
Last September 17, 2019, the DEC issued a “Letter of Incomplete
Application” which rejected the Town’s submission because,among other defects, information necessary to
make findings pursuant to SEQR as previously detailed was not provided, the
Town’s position was “contrary to the letter and spirit of SEQR”, and the Town’s
submission lacked “sufficient detail.” The Suffolk County Department of Health has
also rejected the Town’s submission for similar deficiencies. The Town’s
submissions remain legally deficient and insufficient because no real details
as to the planned development have been provided by CAT.
Mr. Kent’s letter announcing that Arieli Capital, a new unvetted
partner, is “currently working” on a plan of development—two years after the
eligible and qualified hearing-- underscores why the Town lacks authority to
convey the property for a wholly unknown project. The Town and CDA do not have
authority to dispose of a taxpayer asset when it must speculate on the intended
development or public benefit.It is
clear this deficiency is attributable to CAT’s own failure to define its
intentions. CAT itself has said they, “recognize and appreciate the efforts the CDA and the Town
have made to secure the required subdivision approvals.”
CAT Has Failed to Provide Evidence of Its Financial Capability
Multiple press reports
state that Triple Five is delinquent under a $1.4 billion mortgage for its Mall
of America property in Minnesota and has sought state and federal financial
assistance.Riverhead Local has reported
Triple Five has also failed to provide audited financial statements in
connection with its American Dream Mall in New Jersey which is in crisis.Triple Five CEO Don Ghermezian has publicly
acknowledged the potential that the COVID pandemic may cause many malls to
default from their mortgage and financial obligations.
Article XIII of the
Contract provides that purchaser represents it has the financial ability to
complete development of the project. Article XXIII allows the Town to request ‘further
assurances” of CAT’s performance. Statements by CAT to the contrary, evidence of
its ability to perform is not voluntary or a matter of “courtesy”—but required
under the Urban Renewal Law and the Town’s own contract with CAT.
Although you have
requested updated financial statements from CAT, no such statements have been
provided.Press reports of Triple Five’s
financial difficulties and Mr. Ghermezian’s admissions of potential financial
troubles for his family’s existing projects demonstrate, in our opinion, that CAT
lacks ability to finance and develop an aviation or technological hub that will
cost hundreds of millions of dollars in the midst of a recession. The suggestion
in Mr. Kent’s latest letter that the Town must “believe in” CAT and now its new
associates so “investment will flow” is not a substitute for proper financial
documentation, which the Board has requested for months.
The Town must receive substantial
evidence, not wishful thinking. All claims by Triple Five should be subjected
to independent fiscal and legal assessment and cannot be cloaked by proprietary
family interests.The legal and financial
relationship of Arieli Capital to Triple Five must be explained and documented completely
and transparently.
The claim that the well reported
financial difficulties of Triple Five’s Mall of America and American Dream Mall,
and presumed problems of its gambling properties in Las Vegas, have no bearing
on CAT is unpersuasive. CAT consistently
emphasized during the eligible and qualified hearing that its ability to develop
EPCAL was supported by the strength of the Triple Five’s entire consortium of
entities.
CAT also owes to the
Town a complete explanation of its past and current relationship to its increasingly
invisible 25% partner and scientific inspiration Daniel Preston.When did Triple Five become aware of the collapse
of his business in Riverhead and why did it not inform the Town?Why did it pay his debt to Riverhead and was anything
received from him in return? When did it
become aware of the collapse of his business in Little Falls, New York, and the
related suspicious fire?What financial
and legal liability could fall on CAT because of his 25% ownership?What scientific and aerospace advisory or
guidance role does Preston currently play with CAT?If Triple Five has in effect severed its
relationship to Daniel Preston, in order to proceed with the contract is it
prepared to return to the Town the 1050 acres that were gifted to him without
payment?
Absent a well-defined
development plan and specific evidence that CAT can deliver on its promise, the
Town does not have authority to convey the property based on mere speculation. The Town’s actions
are contrary to the General Municipal Law, its own requirements under the Urban
Renewal Law, and the Riverhead Town Code. It is unconscionable, irresponsible
and illegal for the Town to continue to ignore these unequivocal lawful requirements.
Should the Town and CDA continue to ignore these mandates, EPCAL Watch is concerned
that the Town will be legally and financially in jeopardy.
The New Jersey Sports and Exposition Authority asked for proposals in 2002 to redevelop the Meadowlands site in East Rutherford, New Jersey next to the stadium where the New York Giants and Jets play. Xanadu, the developer of the retail, hotel, and office project, began construction in 2005, with a target opening date of 2007. The initial developer ran into money problems, and its successor lost financing in 2010.
Triple Five, owner of the Mall of America in Bloomington, Minnesota, acquired Xanadu in 2011. The authority approved Triple Five’s addition of water and amusement parks in 2013, and construction began in 2015.
The New Jersey Economic Development Authority approved $390 million in tax incentives for Triple Five in 2013, and when the project was delayed, it renewed the tax incentives in 2017.
With backing from the sports authority and the Wisconsin Public Finance Authority, a quasi-public agency, $1.15 billion in tax-free municipal bonds were issued in 2017 to help cover the cost of construction. The bonds are unrated, which means they are particularly risky.
The bonds are to be repaid from sales taxes generated by the complex. The New Jersey Local Finance Board granted Triple Five local redevelopment tax incentives worth up to $800 million in 2015. In addition, state and local authorities have upgraded mass transit and highway access.
Promised Economic Benefits
Triple Five convinced the state to invest in the project by claiming it would create roughly 16,000 jobs, increase tourism to New Jersey, and generate revenue from sales taxes. Triple Five can cash in on the tax incentives only when the massive shopping and entertainment complex opens and begins making money.
State officials expect American Dream Meadowlands will bring New Jersey $3.5 billion in tax revenue over 20 years, including $2 billion in sales taxes and $1.5 billion in corporate taxes, income taxes, and other state taxes.
‘American Nightmare’ Mall?
It is hard to predict whether a shopping mall will be economically viable, and use of reliable numbers is critical, says James R. Barth, Lowder Eminent Scholar in Finance at Auburn University and a policy advisor to The Heartland Institute, which publishes Budget & Tax News.
“[It] requires calculating the expected future benefits and costs, and then determining whether the benefits exceed the costs,” Barth said. “Without such information, it is hard for anyone to determine whether once the mall opens it will make money.”
American Dream Meadowlands might turn out to be a foolish use of New Jersey taxpayers’ funds, Barth says.
“A wise investment is based on a careful calculation of the net benefits and costs of an investment project,” Barth said. “This does not appear to have been done by the governmental officials approving the subsidies in the case of the shopping mall. The “American Dream’ may therefore turn out to be the ‘American Nightmare.’”
Mass Mall Closings
Hundreds of shopping malls in the United States have closed in recent years. Sears, a once-ubiquitous mall retailer, closed another 51 locations at the end of 2019.
Granting billions of dollars in tax incentives for a new shopping mall is a dubious investment when traditional brick-and-mortar anchor stores such as Sears are closing down because of increasing competition from internet sales, Barth says.
“Traditional shopping malls close when they are no longer economically viable,” Barth said. “There is far more competition today from online suppliers of products like Amazon, which adversely impacts the sales of retailers located in shopping malls.”
‘Usually Far Too Optimistic’
Private developers looking for tax incentives often inflate the claimed economic benefits of taxpayer-funded projects, says Art Carden, an associate professor of economics at Samford University.
“Spending government money on private development is rarely if ever a good investment,” Carden said. “We know from the study of things like stadiums, arenas, and convention centers that ‘economic impact’ projections are usually far too optimistic.”
Economic impact studies used to predict outcomes like job creation tend to be unreliable, Carden says.
“Developers are often able to produce a report that justifies, at least in some eyes, claiming the credits,” Carden said. “However, these studies often make questionable assumptions about multipliers and that double- and triple-count the same economic activity.
“They will be able to show just about anything with the right assumptions,” Carden said.
Money ‘Up for Grabs’
Tax incentives for private developers could keep a project alive even if it’s a poor investment, Carden says.
“If a billion dollars is up for grabs, there are a lot of people with strong incentives to keep things moving,” Carden said.
The justification for the mall project is unclear, Barth says.
“Without a defensible economic or financial assessment of the net benefits provided to the public, only the New Jersey government can explain why keeping malls open makes sense,” Barth said.
"American
Dream’s new mega-mall in New Jersey had an early visitor: Miami-Dade’s
mayor" pressure
for public financing of the Florida mega mall, Miami Herald (November 8, 2019)
"The renewed political efforts come as the company continues to meet with the Gimenez administration about public assistance for the $4 billion project outside of Hialeah and Miami Lakes. While Triple Five so far has failed in attempts to secure public dollars for American Dream Miami, the $3 billion sister project at the Meadowlands used about $1 billion in construction money tied to tax dollars."
New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy prepares to ride a roller coaster on Oct. 25, 2019, inside the Nickelodeon amusement park at his state’s version of American Dream, a smaller version in East Rutherford, N.J., of the mega-mall and retail theme park developer Triple Five plans in Northwest Miami-Dade. While the Miami project remains in the planning stages, New Jersey’s American Dream officially opened its doors the day the governor visited. It will showcase 3 million square feet of leasable space dedicated to more than a dozen entertainment attractions like a 16-story indoor ski slope, roller coaster, waterpark and eventually 450 retail, food and specialty shops. DAVE PORTERAP
Two weeks before New Jersey’s American Dream mega-mall finally opened its doors after years of delay, developers led a tour through an unfinished artificial ski mountain and an indoor amusement park for some out-of-town guests with sway over an even larger retail theme park planned off the Florida Turnpike in Miami-Dade.
“Pictures don’t do it justice,” Mayor Carlos Gimenez said of his 3 1/2-hour private visit to the $3 billion Meadowlands project on Oct. 13, where he was joined by chief of staff Alex Ferro and deputy mayor Jack Osterholt. “You have to see it to appreciate it.”
Finally able to show off an American Dream location in New Jersey, Triple Five is using the partially opened Meadowlands site as a showcase for what the company can deliver in Miami.
Days before the Gimenez walk-through, Triple Five flew up a group of Miami pastors, political consultants and business representatives who supported American Dream during the approval process in 2017 and 2018. The group included Sandy Walker, an American Dream outreach consultant and sister of Miami-Dade Commissioner Barbara Jordan, and Pastor Carl Johnson, a Baptist minister from Miami who brought dozens of churchgoers to the commission chambers in 2017 to show support for the jobs American Dream could bring.
Sabrina Piliero, with World Ice Events, practices on the rink at the American Dream mega entertainment and shopping complex in East Rutherford, N.J., Friday, Oct. 25, 2019. The newly opened mega-mall and park by developer Triple Five is a smaller version of one planned in Miami-Dade. After endless fits and starts and billions of dollars spent, New Jersey’s American Dream is officially opening its doors to the public as the second largest mall in the country, and third largest in North America. Richard Drew AP
“The words I choose to use are ‘joy to the land,’” Johnson said of his visit to the New Jersey version of American Dream, which includes an indoor ski slope still under construction and an enclosed amusement park. “They put their heart into it.”
The renewed political efforts come as the company continues to meet with the Gimenez administration about public assistance for the $4 billion project outside of Hialeah and Miami Lakes. While Triple Five so far has failed in attempts to secure public dollars for American Dream Miami, the $3 billion sister project at the Meadowlands used about $1 billion in construction money tied to tax dollars.
Before Miami-Dade commissioners granted near unanimous approval of American Dream’s 200-acre development plan in May 2018, owners of Sawgrass Mills, Bayside Marketplace and other large Miami malls succeeded in inserting language to ban county money from being spent on the project. Triple Five fought the restrictions, calling them illegal and unfair, but Jordan was the only commissioner to vote against them.
Visitors to the American Dream mega entertainment and shopping complex in East Rutherford, N.J., use the Nickelodeon Universe theme park, Friday, Oct. 25, 2019. After endless fits and starts and billions of dollars spent, American Dream is officially opening its doors to the public as the second largest mall in the country, and third largest in North America. Richard Drew AP
And while Triple Five did not ask for government assistance publicly, Gimenez said the request was made early on in the county’s talks with the Canadian company, best known as the owner of Minnesota’s Mall of America. About two weeks after his county-funded trip to visit American Dream in New Jersey, Gimenez played host to Triple Five partner Eskandar Ghermezian in the mayor’s 29th floor office in County Hall. He said the meeting included a discussion of the potential for county financial help and the restrictions against them.
Along with next steps on the new off-ramps and roadwork needed to comply with transportation requirements for American Dream, Gimenez said the two sides also discussed “what incentives may be available from the state and county.”
“We reminded them,” Gimenez said, “about the resolution from the county.”
Triple Five’s Don Ghermezian, a developer of the American Dream mega entertainment and shopping complex in East Rutherford, N.J., is interviewed at the complex, Friday, Oct. 25, 2019. Ghermezian and his father, Eskandar, have been leading the charge for a larger American Dream facility in Miami-Dade. After endless fits and starts and billions of dollars spent, New Jersey’s American Dream is officially opening its doors to the public as the second largest mall in the country, and third largest in North America. The one in Miami would be the country’s largest mall. Richard Drew AP
Miguel Diaz de la Portilla, the lawyer and lobbyist representing Triple Five in Miami-Dade talks, said only that the company had “inquired” about incentives that “may be available” from Miami-Dade.
In New Jersey, Triple Five now has a showcase of both the American Dream concept of a retail theme park, and the way governments can help build one.
Triple Five is the third major developer at the former Xanadu site, taking it over in 2011 after a former effort at a destination shopping mall next to an NFL football stadium failed. The new owner quickly fell behind schedule, too, scrapping a schedule that once had the company planning an Opening Day ahead of the 2014 Super Bowl at MetLife Stadium next door. October only brought a partial opening, with the amusement park and NHL-sized skating rink open to the public but the mall, waterpark, ski slope and other attractions are still under construction.
Government-backed financing was key to reviving the project. Of the $3.2 billion needed to build it, $300 million came from bonds borrowed against a portion of future sales tax revenue collected from the American Dream project. Another $800 million comes from bonds borrowed against a portion of future taxes Triple Five must pay on its property to the surrounding borough of East Rutherford. Those aren’t officially property taxes, but payments in lieu of taxes — a workaround by local and state governments to collect money from the government-owned and tax-exempt Meadowlands complex.
“I have a problem with the state of New Jersey giving $1 billion to this company,” said Mike Doherty, a Republican member of the New Jersey Senate. “Hopefully they’re smarter in Miami than they are in New Jersey.”
James Cassella, the mayor of East Rutherford, said the tax exemptions of the Meadowlands site gave his government little leverage in the American Dream deal and that he’s happy to be receiving yearly payments from Triple Five starting at more than $2 million and eventually hitting $7 million. That’s still small compared to the nearly $40 million going to debt on the project each year, but Cassella said a hefty local tax bill would have killed American Dream at the Meadowlands.
“It wasn’t feasible. They wouldn’t have built it,” he said. Cassella also said he’d be surprised if American Dream Miami went up without public assistance. “I don’t see them doing it without asking,” he said.
The county-dollar restrictions passed in May 2018 cover special tax districts that could let American Dream recoup some of its property taxes, along with “bond financing, grants, loans or subsidies.” It does not cover assistance from Florida, or a limited number of existing economic-development programs in Miami-Dade.
First New Jersey, then Miami? Visitors to the American Dream mega entertainment and shopping complex in East Rutherford, N.J., ride Dora’s Sky Railway, Friday, Oct. 25, 2019. Richard Drew AP
The restrictions were ratified by resolution, meaning a simple majority vote can overturn them at any time. A county mayor can veto commission votes, adding the potential urgency for Triple Five ahead of the 2020 elections. Gimenez is leaving office due to term limits, and two candidates to replace him, former mayor Alex Penelas and current commissioner Daniella Levine Cava, are critics of the project. Levine Cava was the one vote against approval of American Dream’s land-use application, and Triple Five funded a challenger to her 2018 reelection campaign.
She said she doubted an effort to overturn the subsidy restrictions would draw support from the current commission. “It was a very clear expression at the time of the vote,” she said.
Last week, Ghermezian briefly met with Jose “Pepe” Diaz, the Miami-Dade commissioner who sponsored the subsidy restrictions. “They want him to go visit the mall,” said Diaz spokeswoman Olga Vega. Diaz, whose district includes the American Dream site, hasn’t decided whether to accept the invitation, she said.
So far, Triple Five can show off only a partial version of the American Dream concept in New Jersey. Construction workers were still painting walls and laying tile for the retail section of the 90-acre complex during the Oct. 25 opening of the Nickelodeon amusement park inside. The Dreamworks water park and the Snow Park, complete with a ski slope, are expected to be running by December, with the full shopping complex ready for visitors by March.
Construction updates filed with bond regulators show most of the features are close to completion, and American Dream had snow machines running during the recent visits by the Miami delegations. “It was 22 degrees in there. I only had on a suit,” said Eric Knowles, head of the Miami-Dade Chamber, a leading advocate for black-owned businesses. “I didn’t stay in very long. And I grew up in Baltimore.”
Walker, the political consultant, said the trip was designed to give “local supporters” of American Dream a chance to see the New Jersey project. “It was a very good trip,” she said. “It was good opportunity to see what it could mean for Miami-Dade County.”
Triple Five paid for the trip, including a one-night hotel stay, according to Knowles and Johnson, the pastor at the 93rd Street Community Baptist Church. Johnson said he volunteered his time to speak before the commission on behalf of American Dream, and that the company’s only payment was when Walker, working for American Dream, picked up a $500 lunch tab at Miami’s Jackson Soul Food for parishioners after one of the meetings.
Knowles said his interest in the trip was to continue pressing American Dream for opportunities for local businesses. “I think it would be a great boon for the community,” he said.
Even though Triple Five won approval for the Miami-Dade project 18 months ago, it still needs permits and administrative approval for its building plan. But the company has yet to submit site plans to the county, a spokeswoman said. Robert Gorlow, a local consultant for Triple Five, said last month he expected construction to start in about two years.
After his Oct. 30 meetingin Miami with Gimenez, Ghermezian referred most questions to Gorlow and Diaz de la Portilla as they headed for the lobby. Asked how the Miami project was doing, Ghermezian replied: “Come and see. Come to New Jersey, and you’ll say: ‘Oh, I see.’”
A rendering of American Dream Miami, the six-million-square-foot retail theme park planned for Northwest Miami-Dade. County investigators are looking into plans for a sewage project to that area that was originally labeled as for American Dream. That may violate a ban on some county subsidies for the project.
Miami-Dade is ready to spend $15 million on a pipe project needed to extend sewer service to the American Dream Miami mega-mall site near Hialeah, and county investigators are exploring whether the contract violates restrictions on public dollars for the $4 billion retail theme park.
At issue is a September task authorization for design work originally titled “American Dream Mall 24-inch Sanitary Force Main Improvements” but later edited to say it involved building two miles of 24-inch sewage pipes “to service an area of unincorporated Miami-Dade County along NW 170th Street.”
All mentions of American Dream Miami were scrubbed from the final version of the document released to the public.
As the largest mall in America, with plans for indoor lakes and a ski slope, American Dream is expected to create significant demand for water and sewer service in an area that’s currently wetlands and vacant property.
When the Corradino Group, a county contractor, submitted its draft task authorization to the county’s Water and Sewer Department in July, it was titled “American Dream Mall 24-inch Sanitary Force Main Improvements.” It included an extensive description of the proposed development by Canadian firm Triple Five, which also owns Minnesota’s Mall of America.
“As requested,” Corradino vice president Robert Regalado wrote a county engineer on July 24, we “are pleased to submit this revised proposal to the Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department [for] the 24-inch sanitary sewer force main improvements for the American Dream Mall.”
JUST SHORTHAND
The county now says the American Dream mentions in the early versions of the documents were shorthand for that area of Miami-Dade, since the sewer extension will allow hook-ups by a major new housing development and other projects slated to go up near the planned mega-mall.
“Staff just used the most notable and memorable project for internal communication,” Water and Sewer director Kevin Lynskey said Monday in a text message. “When it came time to issue the public docs, the language was made more accurate and inclusive.”
The deletions of the American Dream mentions were cited in a memo the county’s Office of Inspector General sent Lynskey in November seeking more information on the sewage-pipe project.
The Nov. 9 memo from Inspector General Mary Cagle notes “subsequent changes to the name of the project” and “a much more abbreviated description of the purpose of the project” from early drafts of the task order to the one that the department made public.
INSPECTOR GENERAL RAISES CONCERNS
Cagle said attaching the project to American Dream could be problematic, given restrictions on using county dollars to benefit Triple Five’s 175-acre commercial and retail complex where I-75 meets the Florida Turnpike. Constructing the pipe extension will cost about $8 million, with the $15 million cost estimate incorporating engineering and design costs, inspections and other expenses.
“It is also a matter of record that the responsibility for the installation of sewer service has been accepted by the developer(s) of the American Dream Mall and the other properties north of NW 170th Street,” Cagle wrote. She said Triple Five’s willingness to pay for sewer improvements was a “principal reason cited” by county staff in recommending approval of the mega-mall’s zoning application, which the County Commission approved in May.
The extension would run a new two-foot-wide sewage pipe along 170th Street from the existing system on Northwest 78th Avenue to 97th Avenue, about eight blocks south of the proposed American Dream site.
The end point is where the Graham Cos. plans its own massive commercial and residential project as a paired development with American Dream. The Graham Cos. and Triple Five pursued joint approval of their projects, and the Miami Lakes developer owns some of the land that’s part of the mall site. But the commission did not impose restrictions on public funds for the 300-acre Graham project.
PUBLIC FUNDS BATTLEGROUND
Public funds were the primary battleground leading up to the showdown vote by the commission, with a coalition of local mall owners, including the companies behind Bayside Marketplace and Sawgrass Mills, lobbying for legislation passed by commissioners restricting the use of county dollars to help Triple Five.
Commissioner Jose “Pepe” Diaz, who sponsored the no-subsidy legislation for American Dream, said he did not think the sewage project violated those rules. “It’s not just for American Dream,” Diaz said of the sewage project. “If it was exclusively for them, it would not be happening.”
Daniella Levine Cava, the one commissioner to vote against approving American Dream, said she expected Triple Five to lean on government for help as it pursues construction of the largest mall in the country.
“The sewer system,” she said, “is probably just the tip of the iceberg.”
In a response to Cagle, Lynskey wrote that investigators were confusing the rules for sewage projects aimed at certain regions of the county with ones that only benefit a single project. For regional projects, the county pays for the infrastructure while developers fund shorter connections to their properties, Lynskey said.
“It is important to understand how the Department funds regional infrastructure to meet additional service demands that help drive our economy,” Lynskey wrote Cagle.
He said that any sewage extension involving pipes as large as the one heading to the American Dream project are defined as “regional,” since they can serve a large number of projects. Regional pipes are paid from a fund that consists of hook-up fees from small and large projects countywide. Triple Five and Graham eventually would be paying those to Miami-Dade as well.
Once Triple Five is ready to hook up American Dream to the new sewage pipe, it also would pay contractors to install a local connection and Miami-Dade would need to approve the work.
Building the 24-inch pipe also will make it easier for Miami-Dade to keep American Dream and Graham in the county service area, rather than pushing to join Hialeah through annexation, the Water and Sewer Department wrote in a fact sheet about the pipe project.
A county analysis estimated having both massive developments as water-and-sewer customers would generate an extra $2.4 million a year in water fees for the county.
Miguel Diaz de la Portilla, a lawyer and lobbyist representing American Dream Miami, said it would be “inaccurate” to describe the pipe project as designed for his client. The “county is not paying for sewer extension to ADM,” he wrote. Diaz de la Portilla pointed to a string of pending housing projects in Northwest Miami-Dade that would be using the new pipe as well.
The original language of the task authorization identified American Dream as the reason for the county project.
Under the heading “Project Understanding,” Corradino’s submitted draft included two paragraphs describing the American Dream project as “a ‘destination mall’ that will look more like an amusement park than a traditional mall” with “an indoor roller coaster, a lagoon with submarine rides and up to 1,200 stores.”
“To accommodate this proposed development,” the July 20 version of the task authorization read, “the Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department ... has identified the need to extend their wastewater collection and transmission system..”
By the time Water and Sewer released the final task order to the Miami Herald in an October records request, there was no mention of American Dream Miami in the document.
The need to “extend” the county’s sewage system had become a need to “improve it.” And where the draft order talked of extending the sewer pipes to “where the American Dream Mall development is planned,” the final version simply describes a project to “serve the commercial properties ... west of I-75.”