Saturday, April 15, 2023

EPCAL Watch Letters and Articles re IDA


EPCAL WATCH COALITION

156 Youngs Avenue     Riverhead, New York 11901    631.369.8237


         

13 March 2023

Riverhead Town Industrial Development Agency

200 Howell Avenue

Riverhead, New York 11901

 

Dear Chairman Farley and Members of the RIDA Board,


     The redevelopment of EPCAL stands to be the most transformative project for the Town of Riverhead and possibly for the East End region.  On occasion, when faced with complex issues or trailblazing policies, our Town officials have provided a platform for dialog with residents, to provide information, answer questions and receive valuable input.  The success of past efforts to engage constituents is the reason EPCAL Watch is reaching out to you as members of the Riverhead Industrial Development Agency.
     We understand your tentative approval process includes a public hearing on a proposed inducement resolution should one be offered.  The importance of the unique and unprecedented task you have been given cannot be overstated; the input and concerns of the community should not be marginalized and left to the end of your process when you hold the public hearing. Therefore, we are proposing a forum like the ones the Town has held on the transfer of EPCAL from the CDA to the IDA, the water forum, and the cannabis forum. 
     Given the tremendous success of those fora, EPCAL Watch Coalition respectfully requests that RIDA organize and sponsor a similar interactive public forum as soon as possible to collect and exchange information, and to promote awareness, understanding and transparency of the process.  Most importantly, the public will have an opportunity to understand your approach to discharging this incredibly important responsibility on behalf of the people of the Town of Riverhead.

     
We ask that you give this request serious consideration and would appreciate a response in the next week or two either accepting or rejecting our proposal. 

Regards,


Rex Farr, Coordinator

cc:  Board of Directors, Riverhead Town Community Development Agency

       Community Development Administrator Dawn Thomas

       Tracy Stark RIDA Executive Director
       Riverhead Town Clerk


*******************************


EPCAL WATCH COALITION

156 Youngs Avenue      riverhead, new York 11901       631.369.8237


 22 March 2023

 

Michael Caplice, LI Regional Director

NYS OSC

State Office Building, Suites 4A-8A

250 Veterans’ Memorial Highway

Hauppauge, New York 11788

 

RE:  Riverhead IDA Taking on an Impossible Task


 Dear Mr. Caplice:

           In September 2022, the Riverhead IDA (RIDA) accepted a joint application from the Riverhead Community Development Agency (the Town) and the potential purchaser of land at EPCAL--the land had been gifted by the US Navy to the Town in the late 90’s for economic development.  The would-be purchaser is Calverton Aviation Technology (CAT), one of the hundreds of LLCs

created by the Ghermezian family; the sale involves 1600+ acres-- 600 developable acres with 2 runways, and 1000 environmentally protected acres--all for the sum of $40 million.

          Quick recap because this is complicated.  I will try to keep it simple.  The sales contract, signed in 2018, required the Town to file an 8-lot subdivision of the EPCAL land.  When, by May 2020, they had not been able to do so, even though the contract allowed them to terminate the ill-fated deal with the Ghermezians, the Town chose not to, and instead they kept trying to get the DEC permit that was needed for the subdivision.

          So why couldn’t the Town get the DEC permit it needed?  Primarily because CAT’s development plan was too vague and hypothetical to be able to tell if it was consistent with the SEQRA studies that had been done for the EPCAL land, and there was no requisite comprehensive habitat protection plan for the environmentally protected acreage CAT was trying to buy.  No permit meant no subdivision which meant no sale. Stalemate!

          Instead of demanding a definitive development plan from CAT so the permit could be obtained, the Town came up with the bright idea to shift the headache to the RIDA--this they did by filing a joint application with CAT to the RIDA in March 2022.

          The scheme is supposed to work like this.  If the RIDA decides to give the requested tax breaks to CAT, the Town will transfer title to the EPCAL land to the RIDA, and the RIDA will then


lease the land to CAT for its development project.  Bingo, when that happens the Town gets its 40 million dollars--no need for that pesky subdivision approval.  CAT will start building on the leased land and somewhere down the line--we don’t know when--CAT will get the subdivision approved and will then receive title to the property from the RIDA.

          Sounds perfect, doesn’t it?  But will it work?  It shouldn’t if the RIDA follows its normal procedures.  The RIDA, as everyone knows, is in the business of granting tax relief to the developers who can show they will bring projects to the Town that will advance job opportunity, health, prosperity and economic welfare for the residents.  The developer normally comes to the RIDA with all its ducks in a row--an approved site plan, all needed zoning variances and approvals, all required permits and a completed SEQRA review of the project.  The RIDA then looks at the estimated capital costs and the projected number of jobs and completes a cost benefit analysis to determine if the project warrants the tax exemptions the developer is seeking.

          The problem in this case is that CAT has no approved site plan, no zoning approvals, no required permits and no completed SEQRA review.  In fact, the project they described in their presentation to the RIDA is completely different from the state-of-the-art innovative aeronautics and technology center with supportive industries that they have been touting since 2018.  Just this past September though, CAT came clean and told the RIDA the project is for nearly 10 million square feet of warehouses and a cargo airport using both runways.  A cargo airport, however, is not permitted under current zoning and has never been studied for its environmental impact under SEQRA.  In fact, the Town’s latest environmental study, which the RIDA says it’s bound by, specifically states that the property would not be used for cargo or freight!  Add to that the further complication of how CAT gets water and sewer permits for land that has not been subdivided.  And for sure, it can’t start building without an approved site plan which it also does not have.  Nor has a comprehensive habitat protection plan been approved.

          These deficiencies are just the tip of the iceberg to demonstrate what an impossible task the RIDA has undertaken.  The RIDA is not equipped to assess nor should it be considering this “project” in this its larval stage.  It is patently premature to be considering tax abatements at this time.  The Town, not the RIDA, is responsible for overseeing development of the land at EPCAL that was gifted to Riverhead for economic development.  In fact, the section of the Town’s zoning code dealing specifically with the land at EPCAL

(Sections 301-339) says the development of lands there “shall require the submission of a site plan application…subject to Town Board site plan approval.” 

          Clearly, given the posture of this deal, the RIDA should bow out at this time and deny tax inducements for this project.  If and when a site plan has been approved, all necessary permits and variances obtained, and a SEQRA study completed for a cargo airport, then CAT can come back to the RIDA.  But for now, this project is not ready for consideration for tax abatements by the RIDA.

On Behalf of the EPCAL Watch Coalition,

Rex Farr

EPCAL Watch Coalition Coordinator


****************************


Riverhead has a leadership problem

Rendering of CAT's phase 1A development by CAT's architect BLD Architecture.

Riverhead has a fundamental problem that affects all of its residents: Those who are supposed to protect the public routinely don’t. With real consequences.

To see how that harms the many, one need look no further than how close our town is to badly damaging the value of most people’s biggest asset; their homes. We are at the precipice of having a jet cargo airport at EPCAL with the largest runway in the Northeast. Without being told what it will look like, how it will operate, or who will own it. And this is being done to us by our own government.

If this goes through, at least 50 existing homes could be rendered virtually uninhabitable. The market value of hundreds (and likely thousands) more will see their market value reduced. And virtually everyone living in Riverhead is at risk in various ways and to varying degrees of being negatively impacted.

For property owners, the possibilities are stark. While many factors affect noise levels, there are some commonly accepted ideas about planes. Going five miles out in any direction from EPCAL, homeowners can expect to endure jet cargo planes at 1,500 feet of altitude or less, at noise levels ranging from running a vacuum cleaner in the next room to living 50 feet away from the Long Island Expressway. This will be worse at night, because that is when noise is often heard even more clearly.

Some of the thousands of residents who live close to EPCAL (and under the most likely flightpaths) won’t mind. Others will mind a lot. But all of them will be damaged, because (as noted by the US Air Force) at noise levels lower than what we can reasonably expect from cargo jets at 1,500 feet, one out of five people are “highly annoyed” and for some, the noise will actually interfere with the ability to speak to each other. Meaning – among other things – that when a resident wants to sell their home the pool of potential buyers will likely be reduced by at least a fifth and, while they are trying to sell it, the owners may actually find it hard to talk to each other on their own property.

That could explain why the FAA says noise levels lower than those that will likely be experienced in thousands of local homes are “generally incompatible with residential land uses.” Otherwise stated, EPCAL could render many homes in Riverhead incompatible with being a home.

Faced with this quality-of-life cliff, one would expect our government to be actively and vigorously looking out for our interests. Yet the opposite seems to be happening.

Despite being possibly weeks, or even days, away from approval, the approving authorities will not tell us:

Whether EPCAL will or will not be a jet cargo airport. On that score, at some points in the process the answer has been “no.” Then “maybe.” Now, apparently, “yes.”

Who will own it?

What else will be built there? One million feet of additional warehousing? Or is 10 million? We have seen both figures.

What will this look like regarding traffic, site infrastructure (roads, wells, septic, toxic waste clean-up), and environmental issues (multiple endangered species live on the EPCAL site)?

Will the developer actually raise the money to actually build, or instead simply tie up our town’s use of the site for more years.

Despite all of this, the town has actually joined the developer’s application. To make matters worse, the town has manipulated the approval process to circumvent basic requirements that exist to protect us.

Land-use issues are complex, and those raised by EPCAL perhaps even more so. For that reason, let me plainly state that I do not here impugn the motives of any individual public official – elected or appointed – connected with the EPCAL approval process. This is not a criticism about individual people.

But at some point actions (and inactions) have consequences, and results matter. EPCAL is a symptom of a deeper malaise experienced by many communities. Including ours. Which is that we are at a point where we cannot trust our leaders to lead. At least, not behind closed doors. Where decisions like EPCAL that directly impact us are being made.

There is another way. A fusion slate of three registered Democrats and two Republicans has been put together by the Democratic Party for the November elections. I am one of the Republicans. I joined the ticket because it is not about being red or blue. It is about reclaiming Riverhead using common sense drawn from both sides, and not the ideology of one party or the other. With a simple goal: to protect those who live here by stopping.

EPCAL and stopping uncontrolled overdevelopment throughout the town — as well as addressing the wide range of other issues that will determine whether we will retain our unique strengths as a community.

Andrew Leven is a former career federal prosecutor. He lives in Riverhead.

Editor’s note: Leven is a candidate for Riverhead Town Board, running for a council seat on the Democratic line.

https://riverheadlocal.com/2023/03/25/riverhead-has-a-leadership-problem/

*****************************************

The Riverhead IDA must say no to

tax breaks for a cargo hub at 

former Grumman site. Here’s why.

Rendering of CAT's phase 1A development by CAT's architect BLD Architecture.

Instead of cutting through the tangled web they and their predecessors got us into at EPCAL with the Ghermezians and the late Daniel Preston, the Town Board, in a cowardly move, washed their hands of the mess and dumped it into the lap of the Riverhead Industrial Development Agency (IDA). By doing so, they put the IDA in an impossible situation; the IDA needs to extricate itself by saying no to tax inducements — that will put the ball back where it belongs: in the hands of the Town Board. Then the board can and must exercise its right to walk away from this ill-fated deal.

A quick recap because this long dragged-out debacle is complicated.  Way back in 2018, the town signed a contract to sell to Calverton Aviation and Technology (CAT) land at EPCAL : 600+ developable acres with two exceptional runways, and 1,000 environmentally protected acres, all for the embarrassingly low sum of $40 million.  That contract required the town to file an eight-lot property subdivision and secure a NYSDEC Wild, Scenic and Recreational Rivers Act (WSRR) permit.

By May 2020, the town had yet to get the subdivision approved and even though the contract allowed the town to terminate the deal, the Town Board chose not to, and instead kept trying to get the permit from the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation that it needed for approval of the proposed subdivision.  Bad idea. They should have walked fast and far away from this deal.  

So why couldn’t the town get the WSRR permit it needed?  The NYS DEC deemed the application incomplete.  Objections from DEC included:

  • Deficiencies in the town’s Comprehensive Habitat Protection Plan;
  • Deficiencies in the town’s SEQRA consistency analysis;
  • And the town’s failure to get SWCA to consent to the Riverhead Water District supplying water to the site.

No permit meant no subdivision — which meant no sale.  STALEMATE!

The town then came up with the bright idea to shift the headache to the IDA. In March 2022 the town (CDA) and CAT filed a joint application for IDA benefits.

The scheme is supposed to work like this.  If the IDA decides to go ahead with the requested tax breaks, the town transfers its land at EPCAL to the IDA.  The IDA then leases come of the land to CAT for its development project and the rest back to the town.  BINGO! When that happens the town gets its $40 million —no need for that pesky subdivision approval.  CAT will start building on the leased land and somewhere down the line — we do not know when — CAT will get the subdivision approval and will then receive title to the property from the IDA.

Sounds perfect, doesn’t it? But will it work?  Absolutely not if the IDA follows its normal procedures. The IDA, as we all know, is in the business of granting tax relief to developers who can show they have the ability to bring projects to Riverhead that advance job opportunity, health, prosperity and economic welfare for the residents.  The developer usually comes to the IDA with all its ducks in a row — an approved site plan, all needed zoning variances and approvals, all required permits, and a completed SEQRA review of the project.  The IDA then looks at the estimated capital costs of the project, the developer’s ability to finance the project and the projected number of jobs for both construction and operations. The IDA does a cost-benefit analysis to determine if the project’s benefits to the residents of Riverhead warrant the tax exemptions sought by the developer.

The problem with this particular application is that CAT has no approved site plan, no zoning approvals, no required permits and no completed SEQRA review. In fact the project described by CAT during their presentation to the IDA in 2022 is completely different from the state-of-the-art innovative aeronautics and technology center with supportive industries touted since 2017.  Just this past September, CAT came clean and told the IDA its project is for a combination of 10 million square feet of “distribution centers” (not your traditional warehouses) and “flex” buildings as well as an “air cargo hub” using both runways. 

Well, hello! A cargo airport is not permitted under current zoning and has never been studied under SEQRA for its environmental impacts. In fact, the Town’s latest environmental study, which the IDA says it is bound by, specifically states that the property would not be used for cargo or freight. 

Add to that the further complication of how CAT will ever get water and sewer permits for land that has not been subdivided.  How can CAT start construction without an approved site plan — and a comprehensive habitat protection plan that has yet to be approved.

This just scrapes the tip of the iceberg in an effort to show what an impossible task the IDA has undertaken.  The IDA is not equipped to assess, nor should it be considering, this “project” in this its larval stage.  It is simply premature to be considering tax abatements at this time.

Our town, not the IDA, is responsible for overseeing development of the EPCAL lands that were gifted to us for economic development.  In fact, the section of the town’s zoning code dealing specifically with the land at EPCAL (Sections 301-339) says the development of lands there

“… shall require the submission of a site plan application… subject to the Town Board site plan approval.”

Clearly, the IDA should bow out and say no to tax inducements for this project, which it cannot consider anyway because it is not defined or approved.  To do otherwise flies in the face of IDA practices and procedures; it puts the IDA at risk of an audit by the Office of the State Comptroller.

The town’s elected and past Republican Town Board officials are responsible for this horrible deal with CAT.  For these reasons, the IDA should just say no. And when the IDA does so, the town, under the terms of its agreement with CAT, has the right to walk away free and clear — and that’s exactly what must be done.  The people of Riverhead do not want a cargo airport supporting mammoth distribution centers at EPCAL.

Angela DeVito is the Democratic candidate for Town Supervisor. She lives in South Jamesport.


 https://riverheadlocal.com/2023/04/10/the-riverhead-ida-must-say-no-to-tax-breaks-for-a-cargo-hub-at-former-grumman-site-heres-why/


EPCAL WATCH COALITION

156 Youngs Avenue      riverhead, new York 11901       631.369.8237


April 14, 2023

 

Riverhead Industrial Development Agency

542 East Main Street, Suite 1

Riverhead, NY 11901

 

RE:  Joint CDA/CAT LLC RIDA Application

 

Dear Chairman Farley, Members of the Board and Ms. Tracy Stark-James,

 

The Riverhead Industrial Development Agency (RIDA) has begun its due diligence on whether to grant an authorizing resolution that will enable Calverton Aviation and Technology (CAT) to construct an air cargo distribution hub and mega warehouses at EPCAL.  However, we are deeply concerned that RIDA has already compromised its professional standards and ability to evaluate objectively the town's controversial deal with CAT.

As reported in the Riverhead Local on April 8, 2023,

The Riverhead Industrial Development Agency told its independent auditors, Jones, Little & Co. CPAs, that the Calverton Aviation & Technology project “has an anticipated closing date of October 2023,” according to the audited financial statements prepared by the auditors and filed with the Riverhead Town Clerk on March 31. 

 In your own audit letter’s bureaucratic language

 Management has analyzed the results of the Agency for the year ended December 31, 2022, which was a decrease in net position. As such, Management has prepared a going concern evaluation subsequent to year ended December 31, 2022. Included in the evaluation are deposits of $150,000 received in February 2023 from a project [CAT] that has an anticipated closing date of October 2023; $41,000 for a project closing; and $20,200 for normal course of business fees (i.e., annual compliance fees, late charges). Management has indicated that the Agency is also in discussions for another potential project closing by the year ending December 31, 2023. Based upon a prudent budget for the year ending December 31, 2023, and a period thereafter, we believe the Agency will continue as a going concern.

Your projected closing date is just before an election that could turn on citizens' views about whether they believe this deal is good for the town as well as about the impact of an air cargo distribution hub and mega warehouses on their own quality of life and property values.

In addition to foreshadowing that a decision has already been made so that the evaluation process you are undertaking is only for show, the audit letter reveals a serious conflict of interest.

It appears that RIDA is projecting receipt of up to $662,500 in fees from this very controversial deal to finance its own budget.  In fact, the audit letter implies that RIDA will not be able to remain in operation without the income generated by approval.

How can RIDA make an objective judgement about this complicated and unprecedented application if influenced by its need to survive financially?

We hope there are explanations for the language in your audit letter that can be provided in the public forum about how RIDA intends to evaluate the proposal from the Riverhead CDA and the Ghermezian family, as I was assured will occur by Ms. Stark in two phone conversations.

In order to address disquiet among citizens of Riverhead and to meet its obligations under NY State open government laws, rules and regulations to engage the public to the greatest degree feasible in this deliberative process, can you schedule and announce the date of the forum in the near future?

From the beginning, we have had serious doubt about the legality, propriety and viability of the unprecedented burden thrust upon RIDA by the Town Board to avoid its own responsibility to terminate an unfulfilled, one-sided and ill drafted contract.  As a result of the latest revelations, we are asking State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, State Attorney General Letitia James and the Open Government Committee of the Department of State to examine how elected and appointed officials of Riverhead are carrying out their responsibility for governance and protection of the public interest regarding EPCAL.

Sincerely,


Reginald Farr

Coordinator

EPCAL Watch Coalition

 

 cc:  Riverhead Town Supervisor

       Members of the Board/CDA of Riverhead

       Thomas DiNapoli, New York State Controller

       Letitia James, New York State Attorney General

       Shoshanah Bewlay, Executive Director, NYS Committee on Open Government



EPCAL WATCH COALITION

156 Youngs Avenue      riverhead, new York 11901       631.369.8237


May 31, 2023

 

Yvette Aguiar, Riverhead Supervisor

Members of the Town Board


Dear Supervisor Aguiar and Town Board Members,

When the Navy gave the land at EPCAL to the Town of Riverhead, the Town became responsible for its development. This property is the largest industrial subdividable tract in the Northeast and it has been identified by the State of New York in a Special Act as being a uniquely important urban development area. There are a lot of eyes on EPCAL.

CAT’s September 20, 2022 presentation to the IDA depicted a cargo airport and massive distribution center with the potential to generate a volume of air and truck traffic never before experienced in Calverton. The project was crystal clear, the public was paying attention, and we all now know that the Town has a seriously flawed SEQRA (State Environmental Quality Review Act) record on this matter.

The Town as Lead Agency should not let the IDA move forward with an inducement resolution before it corrects the deficient record.   A Lead Agency can reopen SEQRA at any time if there is new information, a change in regulatory circumstances, or significant modification to a project even after Findings have been adopted. The current CAT proposal checks all the boxes for when a Supplemental EIS is warranted. 

As it now stands, the existing SEQRA study is based on an environmental assessment form (FEAF) which was signed by Sean Walter for a 50-lot subdivision in 2013.  A Final Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (FSGEIS) was completed and adopted on March 15, 2016, by the Town Board.  The Findings Statement was adopted on July 19, 2016.  The IDA was not an Involved Agency in that SEQRA review; the IDA was never even mentioned in the FSGEIS.

Thereafter, because the contract with CAT required an 8-lot subdivision, not the 50-lot subdivision that was studied in the FSGEIS, a Consistency Analysis was done April 1, 2019, by Jeffrey Seeman which was adopted by the Planning Board on May 16, 2019.  The analysis was updated on March 25, 2020, and then again on October 12, 2020 but neither was formally adopted by any Board nor accepted by the DEC.

All these documents together constitute the work the Town has done on the project that is now pending before the IDA for consideration of an inducement resolution.  For a plethora of reasons, this SEQRA record remains patently inadequate.

First, although the IDA is now currently faced with a discretionary decision, they were not part of the SEQRA process as an Involved Agency.   The socio-economic section of the EIS only examined impacts at full taxable rates; thus, the projected property tax revenues in the study represented a benefit the community expected. 

Second, the use of the runways for cargo planes was never studied in the SEQRA process.  Clearly, from CAT’s marketing report and plan presented to the IDA, CAT intends to move and extend the taxiways, and use both runways for cargo planes.  Yet, such use was specifically cited in the October 2020 Consistency Analysis Update (p. 15) as a use that would not be happening according to CAT’s counsel and representatives.  In fact, that update says that, while aviation use is permitted on the property, such use is subject to restrictions in the PD Zoning District.  Further, the 10,000 foot runway which is for accessory use of the tenants/owners in the PIP, is subject to Airpark Rules passed by the Town on April 19, 2007 controlling the operation and use of that runway.  The increase in aviation activity as a result of the reactivation of the 7000 foot runway was never studied in SEQRA, and relocation of the runways will directly impact areas identified as prime habitat protection areas including grasslands and woodlands.

Third, the traffic analysis in the completed SEQRA was not modeled using logistics, distribution warehouse figures because, as stated in the October 2020 Consistency Analysis, CAT had represented the property would not be used for cargo or freight operations; rather, the runways and buildings were to be used for aviation technology companies for new and innovative aerospace design of aircraft, electric and solar related avionics. Clearly there was no study whatsoever done of the kind of cargo/freight operation described and pictured in CAT’s presentation to the IDA. The intense truck traffic generated by nearly 9 million sq. ft. of cross-docking distribution buildings was never evaluated. Further, there is no consideration of the cumulative impacts from the multiple logistics warehouse projects currently pending in Calverton outside of EPCAL.

And finally, the Town is now aware that the Navy has discovered additional contamination on parts of the property being sold to CAT.  An investigation is commencing into the nature and extent of the contamination which will determine remediation protocols.  This critical piece of information, along with all the other deficiencies noted above, dictates the need for the Town—the entity ultimately responsible for the disposition and use of this property—to reopen SEQRA. 

There is now a site-specific development plan which is not supported by the SFGEIS.  CAT must demonstrate that the project is within the thresholds and complies with the conditions set forth in the adopted Findings Statements.

The Town Board as Lead Agency must take this opportunity to reopen SEQRA and get it right before it allows the IDA to move forward on the Town’s joint application with CAT.  Failure to do so leaves this Town vulnerable to legal challenges and would be a gross dereliction of your fiduciary responsibility to the community.

Thank you for your consideration and action on these concerns.

Sincerely,

Reginald Farr

Coordinator


 cc:   James Farley, Chair, Riverhead Industrial Development Agency, and Board Members

        Tracy Stark-James, Executive Director, Riverhead Industrial Development Agency

        Dawn Thomas, Executive Director, Riverhead Community Development Agency

        Erik Howard, Riverhead Town Attorney





EPCAL WATCH COALITION

156 Youngs Avenue      riverhead, new York 11901       631.369.8237


June 15, 2023

James Farley, Chairman

Tracy Stark-James, Executive Director

 

Dear Mr. Farley, Ms. Stark-James and members of the Riverhead IDA,


On March 13, EPCAL Watch sent a letter to the IDA that included this request:

“The importance of the unique and unprecedented task you have been given cannot be overstated; the input and concerns of the community should not be marginalized and left to the end of your process when you hold the public hearing. Therefore, we are proposing a forum like the ones the Town has held on the transfer of EPCAL from the CDA to the IDA, the water forum, and the cannabis forum. 

Given the tremendous success of those fora, EPCAL Watch Coalition respectfully requests that RIDA organize and sponsor a similar interactive public forum as soon as possible to collect and exchange information, and to promote awareness, understanding and transparency of the process.  Most importantly, the public will have an opportunity to understand your approach to discharging this incredibly important responsibility on behalf of the people of the Town of Riverhead.”

One month later on April 14, we wrote to you again, containing this reminder:

In order to address disquiet among citizens of Riverhead and to meet its obligations under NY State open government laws, rules and regulations to engage the public to the greatest degree feasible in this deliberative process, can you schedule and announce the date of the forum in the near future?

We never received a written response to either letter.

Despite two verbal assurances from Ms. Stark that our requested forum would take place, we were told informally in conjunction with your last public meeting on June 5 that the IDA is not likely to host a public informational meeting about your process with an open dialogue format.  The presentation by CAT at the Hotel Indigo was obviously not what had been proposed and what we thought had been agreed to and was not an acceptable nor an effective substitute.


In an effort to respond to our request, Vice Chairwoman Pipczynski indicated informally on June 5 that she would explore with the Board and its counsel the possibility of putting some “meat on the bones” of the “Tentative Approval Process” posted on the IDA’s website.  There was also a brief discussion of the possibility of EPCAL Watch submitting questions to the Board in writing. 

Please send written acknowledgement of this letter and the representations contained herein and advise as to your official disposition of our ongoing request for a public forum on the IDA evaluation process of the CAT/CDA joint application.

EPCAL Watch remains fully engaged in the proceedings and transactions of the IDA on the CAT/CDA joint application and we expect transparency to the fullest extent of the law.  

An essential minimum is that the IDA should add to the agenda of its monthly public meetings a substantive update about what has transpired during the previous month regarding EPCAL, so the public is cognizant in real time of the process leading up to your recommendations.

 

Sincerely,

 

Reginald Farr

Coordinator

EPCAL Watch Coalition

 

 

cc:  Riverhead Town Supervisor

       Members of the Board/CDA of Riverhead

       Thomas DiNapoli, New York State Comptroller

       Letitia James, New York State Attorney General

      

****************************************************************************

Affiliated Civic Associations   

               

Audubon Society                          

Brookhaven Group for the        

   East End   

        

Greater Calverton Civic



Greater Jamesport Civic

LI Pine Barrens Society

LI Sierra Club

Northville Beach Civic

Riverhead Neighborhood

  Preservation Coalition

Seatuck Environmental  

     

Sound Shore Heights Civic

Wading River Civic

                                                               

 

 

Reginald Farr, Coordinator

Patricia Aitken                     

Richard Amper

Sid Bail

Phil Barbato

Barbara Blass                      

Karen Blumer

Charles Brevington

Bob De Luca

James Derenze

Michael Foley

Mark Haubner

Christy Hawkins

Mary Ann Johnston

Michael Madigan

Kevin McAllister

John McAuliff

Kathy Mc Graw

Linda Pritzer

Doug Rosenbrock

Rose Sanders

Toqui Terchun

John Turner

Thursday, May 27, 2021

EPCAL Watch Letter Opposing Scrambul Drag Race Permit

 

EPCAL WATCH COALITION

Reginald Farr  Coordinator

Associates

LI Pine Barrens Society

                                    Richard Amper

Group for the East End

Bob De Luca

North Fork Environmental

     Council

                                    Mark Haubner

Defend H2O

Kevin Mc Allister

Open Space Council

Karen Blumer

Michael Madigan

Riverhead Neighborhood

     Preservation Coalition

Phil Barbato

Seatuck Environmental

John Turner

Long Island Sierra Club

Charles Brevington

Audubon Society

Patricia Aitken

Greater Calverton Civic

Toqui Terchun

George Bartunek

Janice Sherer

Greater Jamesport Civic

                                  Patrick Derenze

Northville Beach Civic

Linda Prizer

Kathy McGraw

Sound Park Heights Civic

Michael Foley

Wading River Civic

Sid Bail

 

 

Barbara Blass

Angela De Vito

Christy Hawkins

John McAuliff

Doug Rosenbrock

Rose Sanders

156 Youngs Avenue     Riverhead, New York 11901     631.369.8237

 

 

 

May 26, 2021

 

 

Yvette Aquiar, Supervisor

Members, Riverhead Town Board

Town of Riverhead

200 Howell Avenue

Riverhead, New York 11901

 

RE:      Scrambul Drag Racing at EPCAL

 

 

Madame Supervisor and Members of the Town Board:

 

EPCAL Watch looks forward to the results of your review of the application and contract with Scrambul for use of the runways and adjacent land for drag racing next month.

We are concerned how this project could have come this far without consultation with the civic association and population of Calverton, the hamlet mostly directly affected, and without basic due diligence about the autosports and business credentials of the applicant. 

 

Did you vet the applicant sufficiently to be confident he and his company can fulfill contractual obligations? 

Scrambul was incorporated on December 7, 2020 and has no record of business.  According to its New York State registration it had 1500 shares of stock valued at $.01 per share.  The application shows the same person as President, Vice President, Secretary and Treasurer, hardly the way to describe a real corporation. 

The Town Attorney said at the work session that he was going to request information about prior experience.  What did he find out?  A video was shown to the Board purporting to cover safety provisions but it was an amateurish promotional production.  The Scrambul web site lists six venues for races but only Riverhead is confirmed.

Did Mr. Murphree or his staff in the Planning Department make any effort to have Mr. Baxter correct his woefully inadequate and inaccurate application as was done for Mr. Scalzo?   Why didn’t Mr. Murphree warn the Board of these problems at the work session or Board meeting?

 

Flaws in the Short Environmental Assessment Form

Attached is an EAF generated by the NYSDEC computer app for EAFs.  There are many inconsistencies with Mr. Baxter’s EAF, including

§  its designation of the site not being in a state designated Critical Environmental Area

 

§  the claim there will be no substantial increase in traffic.  With 1000 attendees already purchasing racer and spectator tickets, how could there be no traffic? 

 

§  the claim that the site does not contain any species of animal or their habitats listed as threatened or endangered.  This is patently false and should have been picked up by the Town reviewers

 

§  the claim that the site is not the subject of remediation for hazardous waste, also patently false and should have been

 

§  the claim that the grasslands, and therefore grassland dependent bird species and other wildlife, will not be adversely affected. It was stated that there will be no activities on the grass yet that is not what the diagrams of the two runways show.  Those illustrations show handicap and paddock parking, timing trailers, and fire/rescue vehicles in the grasslands.  

 

§  the total acreage of the site of the proposed action is shown as 2921 acres.  Do they intend to use all of EPCAL? 

 

§  total numbers on one or both days could easily exceed 1,000 including racers, spectators, children, staff, volunteers, vendors, security, etc.  That possibility obligates a mass gathering permit.  [“Special event large gathering. Where 1,001 to 4,000 attendees are expected at the event per calendar day”]

Will the town independently monitor numbers admitted to the site on each day and require admissions be halted if the total number present will exceed 1000?   Have you seen their sales reports that indicate tickets sold to racers, including "crew members", and number of one day spectator passes for Saturday and for Sunday as well as two day passes?

 

Problems in the Special Events Application

§  Andre Baxter is entered as a “person residing in Suffolk County”, but his residence is in Hempstead in Nassau County.  On one of the affidavits he gives an address of Long Island City, Queens.  What are the implications of not being a Suffolk County resident for the application, for additional payments for “day-of” services, and for the Hold Harmless obligation? 

 

§  The total people per day and per hour is listed as 150.  What is the revised figure?  Do spectators at such events stay for the rest of the day once they enter or remain only for an hour or two?  As noted above, have you seen their sales reports that indicate tickets sold to racers, including "crew members", and the number of one day spectator passes for Saturday and for Sunday as well as two-day passes?

 

§  The Parking section is out of date, indicating 250 parking spaces on site and none off-site.  What are the revised numbers?

 

It is necessary to issue a Rescission of the Type II/Negative Declaration and replace it with a Type I/Positive Declaration

The questionable Type II SEQR designation is presumably based on NYCRR 617.5(b )(21) which states: "(21) minor temporary uses of land having negligible or no permanent impact on the environment". While one could reasonably argue that the use proposed will not have permanent impacts, they are hardly negligible given their potential impact on grassland dependent wildlife at the worst possible breeding and nesting time.  

The size of the event requires Type I pursuant to NYCRR 617.4(bI)(6)(iii) as follows:

(6) activities, other than the construction of residential facilities, that meet or exceed any of the following thresholds; or the expansion of existing nonresidential facilities by more than 50 percent of any of the following thresholds:

(iii) parking for 500 vehicles in a city, town or village having a population of 150,000 persons or less;

Scrambul has sold tickets for four hundred cars to participate as competitors.  Ticket sales for spectators are at least six hundred.  Additional staff, volunteers, crew members and vendors are likely to increase the number of vehicles over the 500 limit.  Presumably some of the cars will be brought on truck drawn trailers which will remain on the grounds.

Type I classification and issuance of a positive declaration requires preparation of an EIS which would go into granular detail about all aspects of the proposal and require a discussion of mitigation measures and reasonable alternatives as follows: 

 

(v) a description and evaluation of the range of reasonable alternatives to the action that are feasible, considering the objectives and capabilities of the project sponsor. The description and evaluation of each alternative should be at a level of detail sufficient to permit a comparative assessment of the alternatives discussed. The range of alternatives must include the no action alternative. The no action alternative discussion should evaluate the adverse or beneficial site changes that are likely to occur in the reasonably foreseeable future, in the absence of the proposed action. The range of alternatives may also include, as appropriate, alternative:

(a) sites;

(b) technology;

(c) scale or magnitude;

(d) design;

(e) timing;

(f) use; and

(g) types of action.

 

 

Unanswered Questions

 

We assume many if not all of the following questions are already on the lists of the town’s professional staff and in your minds as you consider how to resolve the many problems associated with this event.

§  Where is Exhibit A (a depiction of the premises) mentioned in paragraph B of the Short Term Runway  Agreement with Scrambul that is the subject or Resolution CDA 2021-5? 

 

§  Is this missing depiction a revision to the Scrambul site plans they displayed at the April 29th Town Board work session?

 

§  Has Scrambul submitted any revised site plans or are those from the April 29th work session still accurate?

 

§  How can Scrambul make the active FAA runway, Runway 14/32, available and prevent any use of it that might interfere with the runway’s use when the Scrambul site plan shows concessions and restrooms will be located on that runway not to mention two drag racing tracks?

 

§  The Scrambul site plan shows parking along runway 14/32. Is that still the plan?  If so why does the Runway Agreement at #13 talk about a parking plan to be submitted not less than 14 days before the start of the Term of the Agreement (Term of the Agreement starts June 17 so plan must be submitted by June 3rd) and why is there mention of shuttle service and authorization from owners of property that may be used for parking?

 

§  Is the yet to be revealed traffic plan (also due by June 3rd) to be implemented by a private company not the Town Police?

 

§  How can the Town give Scrambul exclusive rights to the use of these two runways for this event when the Town has another lessor, Robotics Inc, that leases and uses a portion of these runways?

 

§  How and where will spectators be controlled? The Scrambul site plan shows a small area for spectators adjacent to runway 14/32.  Will there be a fence around the area? At the work session, Scrambul said spectators will not be permitted to go to Runway 5/23:  how will they be kept from going there? How will they be kept off the protected grasslands?

 

§  The Scrambul website says there will be no bleachers but spectators can bring chairs and EZ tents.  Where can they set these up?

 

§   In social media there have been references to overnight camping or parking at the site.  Has that been discussed and/or explicitly prohibited?

 

§  The Scrambul site plan shows only a fence between the spectators and the race track, no concrete barrier. Member Rothwell at the work session asked for a revision of the placement of concrete barriers. Has that revision been received? What does it show? 

 

§  What kind of concrete barriers will be used?  Jersey or Texas barriers such as used during highway construction?  How many will be rented and brought it by special trucks? 

 

§  The proposed Short Term Runway Use Agreement, Paragraph D states that Scrambul shall pay rent for, "Surface use for Runway 5/23 and Runway 14/32, associated taxiways, and other areas".  What are these unnamed "other areas"?

 

§  Because Scrambul has no established corporate identity or credit record, will you apply 255-10 D?  “The Town Board may require the applicant to provide a letter of credit, bond or other suitable security instrument to secure compliance with conditions in the permit for an event to be conducted on Town property and to insure adequate cleanup of the property after the event. The Town Board shall set the amount by resolution, and no permit shall be issued until the security has been provided to the Town Clerk”

 

§  Have you ascertained the views and received clearance about drag racing at EPCAL from the Suffolk County Department of Health, the Department of Environmental Conservation, the Calverton National Cemetery, the Gold Star Mothers and the residents of Calverton and other nearby communities?   Has a completed application as revised been filed with the Suffolk County Department of Health Services?

 

§  Is Scrambul planning to add any chemical or material to the surface of the runways?  Will it be cleaned off after the two days of races?  Is there any risk of surface or water contamination in bordering areas?

 

§  Did each member of the Board receive notice of the Fire Marshall’s findings and review them?  Has that now occurred?  Is it available to the public?

 

§  What state and local laws, rules and regulations were used as indices of sufficient compliance?

 

§  Are the Standard Operating procedures [SOPs] and policies referred in the application attached to the public safety plan?

 

§  Are the EMT/EMS staff members the only emergency personnel that will be on-site?

 

§  Is the Manorville Volunteer Fire Department going to be on-site for the entirety of the event?  If not, what is their anticipated time of arrival as needed? And who will intervene until they arrive?  What other fire departments have signed on to assist?

 

§  What type of staffing, including volunteers?  What are their qualifications and credentials to perform requisite services including but not limited to EMT/EMS?  For example, have staff been trained in traffic zone safety?

 

§  Is there a separate first aid tent for spectators or are services for possible non-life-threatening injuries incorporated into the anticipated EMT/EMS services?

 

§  Is it realistic to project that the EMS access time to an incident via each of the four access points mentioned in the plan is only two minutes?

 

§  There appear to be provisions for evacuation of staff, autos and associated auto drivers/staff.  But where are the provisions for the spectators?

 

§  Have all the vendors been identified?  Do all have the requisite SCDOH permits?

 

§  Is the signage sufficient?  Where exactly will they be located to allow for ease of viewing?  The event maps/plans do not show such. 

 

§  1,000 spectators and their cars now anticipated, what is the number of portable toilet facilities that will be available?  (Estimates of usual use call for about 23 uni-sex units, not counting ADA compliant units.)  How many units will be ADA compliant?  How many times a day will they be cleaned?  Will each unit have hot and cold water available for handwashing as well as single use towels for hand drying?  Will facilities for female patrons be equipped with sanitary item disposal containers?  Will there be attendants/volunteers present to assist with maintenance, ensuring the units remain clean and sanitary? 

§  What materials will be used to suppress/put out any fires/explosions that may occur as the result of an accident/mishap?  Do we have the MSDS sheets for these substances?  Do any of the firefighting materials contain regulated chemicals such as PFOS?

 

§  What chemical substance will be used to enhance track traction?  How is it disposed of once it is applied to the runways?

 

§  How many trash/waste material containers/barrels will be on-site?  How often will they be emptied during each of the 12-hour days?

 

§  Will spectators be allowed to bring in coolers and food stuff?  How will the event applicant control for on-site use of alcoholic beverages, whether they arrive with the event goers or are sold by vendors?

 

§  Is the Town of Riverhead, including our EMT/Ems services and police services [our traffic control officers] going to be assigned to this event?  If so, what are the anticipated costs to the Town and how will these be met?  Will staff be taken off normal operations and assigned to EPCAL?

 

§  Has the Police Chief reviewed the proposed traffic control measures, and if so can his findings/report please be shared with us?

 

§  How will Town re-coup money spent to have Town employees at the site each day of the event?  Has a budget for projected salaries and benefits been developed and presented as an appendix to the proposed contract?

 

For the above reasons and pending questions as citizens of Riverhead, we see no alternative but to rescind the approval under article § 255-13. “statements contained in the application are materially inaccurate” and accordingly, permanently table the proposed contract until a new application is approved.  If a more accurate application is presented, we hope it will satisfactorily address the following problems:

Additionally these requirements from Chapter 255, Article II - Special Events of the Code have not been met:

 

Section 255-9C(4) - application must include an environmental impact study

 

Section 255-11B - in determining whether to approve or deny an application the Town Board shall consider the information provided including: (1) the environmental impact study

 

(8) - verification that the information contained in the application is not found to be false or nonexistent in any material detail.

 

Sincerely,

 

Rex Farr

Coordinator